The Challenge of Smaller Creators in a Brand-Focused Google Landscape
In digital marketing, search engine optimization (SEO) has long been a cornerstone strategy for businesses of all sizes to increase their online visibility and drive traffic through organic search results.
However, as Google continues to adapt its algorithms and prioritize larger brands with established authority, many are questioning whether SEO is becoming less effective for smaller creators and niche players in this competitive environment.
Some experts say it’s even simpler – suggesting that if you aren’t spending big money on Google Ads, you won’t rank on Google Search, something Google has denied for a long time.
In the previous week before I’ve written this article, I’ve seen some significant SEO experts talk about switching into content marketing, talk about leaving SEO because Google simply won’t pay attention to smaller brands anymore, and I’ve even seen SEO stalwarts shutting down blogs and other digital assets.
I’m sure you’ve seen this before… but maybe this time it’s actually real?
👇
The Evolving SEO Landscape
SEO has historically been a game-changer for smaller businesses, allowing them to compete on a more level playing field with larger enterprises.
The core principle of SEO is to optimize content and website structure to improve rankings on search engine results pages (SERPs).
For years, on-page optimization, quality content, and backlinks were the golden trifecta for achieving strong visibility in search results.
However, as Google has evolved its algorithm—most notably with updates like Panda, Penguin, and more recently, Core Web Vitals—the search engine has increasingly favored established, authoritative brands.
This shift raises a critical question: Is SEO still a viable strategy for smaller brands, or has it become a continuously uphill battle against the giants?
👇
The Rise of Big Brands
Recent updates and Google’s ongoing focus on user experience have led to the prioritization of well-established brands that have earned significant authority over time.
Factors such as domain authority, backlink profiles, and overall trustworthiness are often skewed in favor of larger enterprises that can afford extensive marketing budgets and resources.
This phenomenon has left smaller creators with the feeling that no matter how high-quality their content is, it is often drowned out by louder, more established voices.
Additionally, Google’s emphasis on local searches—where businesses with a robust presence or reputation in a given area tend to shine—can make it difficult for smaller players to break through, especially in competitive niches where big brands already have a foothold.
👇
The Challenge for Smaller Creators
- Limited Resources: Smaller creators often operate with constrained budgets, which can limit their ability to invest in SEO tools, professional services, and continued learning to stay updated with evolving trends.
- Authority Gap: As mentioned, the authority dilemma means that even quality content may not rank well because it simply lacks the domain authority that larger sites possess. This creates a vicious cycle where lower rankings result in less visibility and fewer backlinks, compounding the issue over time.
- Content Saturation: With the proliferation of content on the internet, smaller creators face significant challenges in standing out among the noise. Google frequently updates its algorithms to prioritize fresh, authoritative, and user-focused content. For smaller creators, this means not only creating high-quality content but also ensuring that it resonates with users and meets specific search intents.
👇
Strategies for Survival and Growth
Despite these challenges, SEO is not without hope for smaller creators. Here are several strategies that can be effectively employed:
- Niche Targeting: By identifying and creating content around specific niches or long-tail keywords, smaller creators can find their unique space within search results. This allows them to compete more effectively against larger brands in less-saturated areas.
- Building Authority Gradually: Smaller creators should focus on building their domain authority through consistent quality, building relationships within their niche, and obtaining backlinks from relevant, authoritative websites.
- Leveraging Community and Engagement: Small brands can foster community engagement through social media, newsletters, and forums. By creating and nurturing a dedicated audience, they can drive organic traffic and enhance their visibility.
- Multichannel Marketing: Diversifying their marketing efforts to include social media marketing, content marketing, and email marketing can supplement organic search traffic, helping smaller creators build audience loyalty and brand recognition.
- Continuous Learning: Staying updated with the latest trends in SEO and search engine algorithms is vital. Continuous learning through resources, webinars, and SEO training can equip smaller creators with the strategies needed to pivot as conditions change.
👇
Conclusion
As Google trends increasingly favor established brands, it can often feel like the landscape is becoming less hospitable for smaller creators.
However, SEO is not inherently less effective; rather, its application and strategies must evolve.
By embracing niche marketing, content marketing, building authoritative connections, and leveraging diverse promotional channels, smaller creators can still carve out significant presence and visibility in the digital world.
SEO remains a relevant and effective tool—it just requires a more nuanced approach in a brand-dominated landscape. For example we’ve noticed one business, Budget Car Sales in Auckland, winning in SEO mostly via their images being found online, more than their webpages.
Also, smaller businesses might consider slashing their overall SEO budget and just focus on Local SEO – learn more HERE. Consider a company like Solartive in New Zealand – they only service one specific region, so the efforts of Local SEO are paying dividends, whereas if they were a national level company, I’m not so sure.
Final Point: I personally am closing down our general SEO business, to focus SOLELY on Local SEO as I can see the value and longevity remaining, when compared to general SEO.
Feel free to reach out and ask us more, contact details below:
More Information:
👉 Marketers List – Find Trusted Marketing Professionals
👉 Blog
👉 Contact Us